2027
| Name | High School | College / University |
| Clark Bucher | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Michigan |
2026
| Name | High School | College / University |
| Grant Davis | Boonville High School | Anderson University |
| Jackson Ficklin | Evansville North | Rend Lake CC |
| Sean Frey | Fishers High School | Anderson University |
| Luke Gremelspacher | Guerin Catholic | Indiana Wesleyan |
| Owen Lukac | Fishers High School | University of Evansville |
| Rykin Matthias | North Central High School | Bellarmine University |
| Kade McConnell | Castle High School | Indiana Wesleyan |
| Lucas Musser | Peru High School | Saint Xavier University |
| Alton Ostby | Washington High School | Indiana State |
| Vinny Pecoraro | Fishers High School | Anderson University |
| Eli Sinsabaugh | Cathedral High School | Army |
| Mikey Stapleton | Lafayette Central Catholic | DePauw University |
| Nathan Sutherlin | Greencastle High School | Marian University |
| Tyler Tevault | Evansville Memorial | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Hayden Werner | Fishers High School | Maryville University |
| Jake Winger | McCutcheon High School | Indiana University |
2025
| Name | High School | College / University |
| Maddux Bach | Hamilton Southeastern High School | University of Indianapolis |
| Brady Carmann | Fishers High School | Indiana Tech |
| Zander Carnahan | Fishers High School | Amherst College
|
| Luke Cherry | Fishers High School | Grace College |
| Zander Cobb | Greenfield Central High School | Franklin College |
| Jude Coursey | Crawfordsville High School | Olivet Nazarene University |
| Mayo Fernandez | Fishers High School | Grace College |
| Issac Flamino | Kokomo High School | Southeastern CC |
| McCoy Fulk | Noblesville High School | Purdue Fort Wayne |
| Grant Gearhart | Fishers High School | Spalding University |
| Zach Haahn | East Peoria High School (IL) | Highland CC |
| Luke Hagelskamp | Noblesville High School | Black Hawk College |
| Micheal Hoog | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Depauw University |
| Josh Lesniewski | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Depauw University |
| Cade Lile | Zionsville High School | Trine University |
| Matthew Poyer | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Lincoln Land CC |
| Deagan Repp | Fishers High School | Indiana Tech |
| Aiden Riser | McCutcheon High School | Huntington University |
| Tyler Sarver | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Grace College |
| Jacob Stenger | Oldenburg Academy | Earlham College |
| Joe Washburn | South Bend St. Joseph | Creighton University |
2024
| Name | High School | College / University |
| Owen Backofen | Fishers High School | University of Indianapolis |
| Nathan Bodenberg | Westfield High School | Hanover College |
| Wyatt Burris | Hagerstown High School | Knox College |
| Nathan Criss | Mt. Vernon High School | Wabash College |
| Jack Dowell | Lafayette Harrison High School | Spaulding University |
| Josh Ferguson | Evansville Central High School | Marshall University |
| Ben Hirschy | New Palestine High School | Saint Xavier University |
| Ethan Lund | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Purdue University |
| Ian Potts | Peru High School | Anderson University |
| Logan Marsell | McCutcheon High School | Wabash Valley |
| Cole Noreuil | Delavan High School | John A. Logan CC |
| Cam Sullivan | Mt. Vernon High School | University of Notre Dame |
| Preston Tamm | Westfield High School | Manhattan College |
| Deklan Thompson | Mooresville High School | Huntington University |
| Cole Tracy | Hagerstown High School | Bluffton University |
| Lane Wadle | Greenfield Central High School | Georgia Tech University
|
2023
| Name | High School | College / University |
| Isaac Bair | Lapel High School | Anderson University |
| Garrison Barile | Center Grove High School | Miami (Ohio) University |
| Matthew Becher | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Bluffton University |
| Ty Bradle | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Ball State University |
| Jace Burton | Silver Creek High School | Indiana State University |
| Adyn Collins | North Posey High School | Quincy University |
| Cale Coursey | Crawfordsville High School | Parkland Community College |
| Brendan Gothrup | Lafayette Harrison High School | Lincoln Trail CC |
Oliver Hamilton
| Gibson Southern High School | Oakland City University |
| Brock Harper | Lapel High School | University of Indianapolis |
Alec Hershberger
| Fairfield High School | Taylor University |
| Owen Imel | Lapel High School | Huntington University |
| Dylan Keever | Noblesville High School | Indiana University – Kokomo |
| Carter Klein | Carmel High School | Lake Land CC |
| Asa Koeppen | Lafayette Jeff High School | Purdue Northwest |
| CJ Mastagh | South Bend Adams High School | Kaskaskia College |
| Max McCammon | Bloomington South High School | Anderson University |
| A J Oden | Greenfield Central High School | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Zack Pelletier | Penn High School | Huntington University |
| Ethan Pickering | Rensselaer Central High School | University of Indianapolis |
| Austin Penry | Frankfort High School | Lake Land College |
| Evan Rainey | Lafayette Jeff High School | William Woods College |
| Dominic Sharp | Boonville High School | Maryville University
|
| Landon Shellhaas | Evansville North High School | University of Missouri, St. Louis |
| Rylee Singleton | Evansville North High School | Taylor University |
| Ty Starke | St. Xavier High School | University of Louisville |
| Zachary Stawski | South Bend St. Joseph High School | Anderson University |
| Nick Wangler | Evansville Memorial High School | Wabash College |
| Maddux Yohe | Mishawaka High School | Anderson University |
2022
| Name | High School | College / University |
| Cohden Brubaker | Leo High School | Indiana Tech University |
| Jakob Byler | Fort Wayne Snider High School | University of St. Francis |
| Jake Creech | Homestead High School | Marian University, Wisconsin |
| Chase Daffron | Center Grove High School | Indiana Tech University |
| Oliver Hamilton | Gibson Southern High School | Oakland City University |
| Brock Harper | Lapel High School | University of Indianapolis |
| Nicholas Hockemeyer | Homestead High School | Ivy Tech |
| Cam Howard | Hamilton Southeastern High School | Western Illinois University |
| Carter Lile | Zionsville High School | Huntington University |
| Trevor Newman | Fort Wayne Snider High School | Franklin College |
| Will Mayer | Cathedral High School | St. Edwards University |
| Colton Okes | Gibson Southern High School | Wabash Valley CC |
| Zayden Stiller | New Palestine High School | Anderson University |
| Jadon Stoner | Corydon Central High School | Quincy University |
| Justin Tucker | Benton Central High School | University of St. Francis |
| Zach Wade | Batesville High School | Adrian College |
Previous Years
