| Brendan Burns | RHP 2014 | Ball State University |
| Nathaniel Rhodes | RHP 2014 | Marshall University |
| Michael Chakiry | RHP 2014 | Vincennes University |
| Luke Dietz | RHP 2014 | Eastern Illinois University |
| Trevor Salmon | LHP 2014 | University of Southern Indiana |
| William Anderson | RHP 2015 | Northern Illinois University |
| Dalton Leighty | RHP 2016 | Wabash Valley CC |
| Andrew Bohm | RHP 2016 | Purdue University |
| Tyler Hofmann | RHP 2016 | St. Joseph's College |
| Jacob Hurtubise | OF 2016 | Army |
| Carter Poiry | RHP 2016 | Western Illinois University |
| Michael Pachmayer | LHP 2016 | Ball State University |
| Matt Gorski | OF 2016 | Indiana University |
| Blake Malatestinic | RHP 2017 | Eastern Illinois University |
| Drew Reckart | SS 2017 | Ohio State University |
| Jay Hammel | RHP 2018 | Quincy University |
| Grant Johnston | RHP 2018 | Purdue University Fort Wayne |
| Alex Klotz | RHP 2018 | Uncommitted |
| Tyler Knepley | RHP 2018 | Marian University |
| Tyler Jahanshahi | OF 2018 | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Drew Switzer | RHP 2018 | Spalding University |
| Jon Vore | RHP 2019 | Butler University |
| Seth Baugh | RHP 2019 | College of Central Florida |
| Jeff Bryant | LHP 2019 | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Parker Bard | RHP 2020 | University of Dayton |
| Marcus Goodpaster | RHP 2020 | Hanover College |
| Ben Thompson | RHP 2020 | John A. Logan CC / Florida International University |
| Kaleb Applebey | RHP 2021 | Louisiana State University |
| Diego Cardenas | RHP 2021 | University of Indianapolis |
| Hunter Dobbins | C 2021 | Ball State University |
| Aric Ehmke | RHP 2021 | Frontier CC |
| Enas Hayden | RHP 2021 | Purdue University Fort Wayne |
| Zach Nehlsen | RHP 2021 | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Trey Reed | RHP 2021 | Indiana State University |
| Khal Stephen | RHP 2021 | Purdue University |
| Cam Howard | RHP 2022 | Western Illinois University |
| Ty Starke | LHP 2023 | University of Louisville |
| Alec Hershberger | LHP 2023 | Taylor University |
| Carter Klein | RHP 2023 | Lake Land CC |
| Ty Bradle | RHP 2023 | Lincoln Trail CC |
| Cameron Sullivan | RHP 2024 | Notre Dame |
| Ethan Lund | LHP 2024 | Purdue University |
| Logan Marsell | RHP 2024 | Uncommitted |
| Matthew Becher | RHP 2024 | Bluffton University |
